My first Indie polish is Pahlish Lonesome Ocean. It is a dark teal jelly base with black, blue, pink and gold glitter in it. It dries matte, but the glitter really stands out with a glossy topcoat. This is three coats of Lonesome Ocean with one coat of HK Girl topcoat. It did cover completely in three coats, but next time I wear it, I think I will put it over a dark blue base. I bought this in 2013 and it still has a good formula and no staining, which I was a bit surprised about because it is such a deep teal shade.
Are you an Indie polish lover? I'd love to hear what your first Indie polish was in the comments below!